Millions of drivers waiting for compensation over mis-sold car finance could face significant delays following fresh legal challenges against the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
Three major lenders have launched legal action against the regulator over its proposed £9.1 billion mass redress scheme. This latest development comes shortly after the consumer group Consumer Voice also challenged the FCA's plans, meaning the scheme is now facing pressure from both sides of the debate.
Why is the redress scheme being challenged?
CA Auto Finance, Mercedes-Benz Financial Services, and Volkswagen Financial Services have all brought legal challenges against the FCA. While the specific details of the challenges have not been fully disclosed, Volkswagen Financial Services stated that it has identified issues that require independent clarification by the courts.
Mercedes-Benz and CA Auto Finance have declined to comment on the ongoing legal proceedings. The FCA has confirmed it will defend the scheme robustly in court, stating that it engaged extensively with lenders and consumer groups to create a fair framework.
The legal action from lenders compounds existing challenges to the redress scheme. As previously reported, the consumer group Consumer Voice has already launched a legal challenge, arguing that the FCA's compensation formula leaves drivers out of pocket.
Consumer Voice raised concerns that the scheme uses a minimum compensatory interest rate of 3%, whereas courts typically award 8%. The group also argued that the calculations underestimate the financial harm suffered by drivers and limit full refunds for undisclosed commissions to a small group of cases.
Will compensation payouts be delayed?
The scheme is designed to cover around 12.1 million car finance agreements taken out between April 2007 and November 2024, with average payouts estimated at £830.
Under the original timeline, the FCA expected millions of claims to be paid out by the end of 2026. However, with multiple legal challenges now in motion, delays are highly likely. Depending on court schedules and potential appeals, the timeline for payouts could be pushed back into 2027.
What to do if you think you are affected
Despite the legal uncertainty, consumer guidance remains the same. If you believe you were overcharged on a car finance agreement, you can still take action:
- Complain to your lender directly - Submitting a complaint now ensures your details are on record. This is vital as lenders can delete customer records after six years.
- Avoid claims management companies - Complaining directly to your lender is free. Third-party claims companies often take a significant cut of your final compensation, sometimes 30% or more.
- Wait for updates - If your lender has already acknowledged your complaint, you do not need to do anything else. You are in the system and will be contacted once the scheme is implemented.
MTTM AI (beta) 
