Vanguard SIPP review

11 min Read Published: 11 May 2020

In this article we review the long-awaited Vanguard SIPP, detailing the cost, minimum investment and the cheapest way to invest in Vanguard funds via a pension, which isn't necessarily by using the new Vanguard SIPP. You can jump straight to the section 'How to get the cheapest Vanguard SIPP.

Vanguard had been promising a pension product for some time now, with investors having to patiently wait it out. Vanguard launched its Vanguard Investor platform in the UK in May 2017, initially offering an ISA, a junior ISA and a general investment, with the promise of a pension product in the future and on February 19th 2020, Vanguard finally announced the launch of the Vanguard SIPP.

What are the costs of the Vanguard SIPP?

The charges for the Vanguard SIPP are as follows:

  • annual account fee of 0.15%, capped at £375.
  • ongoing fund charges ranging from 0.06% to 0.80%.

Vanguard does not charge an additional annual SIPP administration fee, unlike many other SIPP providers that usually charge around £10 per month. That being said, it is not necessarily the cheapest way to invest in a Vanguard SIPP which we explain in more detail below.

What is Vanguard SIPP minimum investment amount?

The Vanguard SIPP has a minimum monthly investment of £100 or you can start with a lump sum of £500. Given that Vanguard is well-known for being low cost and is popular among both beginner and seasoned investors, I expected the minimum investment to be lower. There has been a lot of excitement surrounding the Vanguard SIPP and the higher than expected minimum investment means that some consumers looking to start saving into a pension will have to look elsewhere. Interactive Investor, for example, is one of the cheapest ways to invest in Vanguard funds (and can be cheaper than investing via the Vanguard's SIPP) but helpfully there is no minimum investment requirement. Read the section 'How to get the cheapest Vanguard SIPP below.

Alternatively, if you want the cost savings associated with using passive trackers but with someone else making the investment decisions for you then there are robo-advice propositions such as Wealthsimple which have no minimum contribution levels on their main pension portfolios.

Does the Vanguard SIPP have any setup or exit charges?

No, the Vanguard SIPP has no setup or exit charges. Additionally, there is no annual administration fee and no charge when going into drawdown.

Should I invest in the Vanguard SIPP?

For a full review of Vanguard, check out our independent Vanguard Investor review, which looks at Vanguard as a platform, its products and how it compares to its competitors. Our independent Vanguard review also looks at the fees, the funds available as well as the fund performance and is an essential read if you are considering investing in the Vanguard SIPP. If you like Vanguard funds and cost is an important factor, read on as we explain how you can get a Vanguard SIPP cheaper than investing with Vanguard directly.

How to get the cheapest Vanguard SIPP

Interactive Investor  (also known as ii) is the second largest investment platform in the UK and what makes it attractive is that it operates a fixed monthly fee model, with three different service plans on offer. Most platforms will charge a fee based on a percentage of your holding, with Vanguard itself charging a capped 0.15% fee. Our research shows that if you hold more than £160,000 in Vanguard funds, then investing via an Interactive Investor SIPP would actually be cheaper than investing via a Vanguard SIPP. This is because Interactive Investor charges a monthly fee of £9.99 via its cheapest service plan, plus an administration charge of £120 per year, meaning the maximum total fees you will pay in a given year is £239.88 compared to a maximum of £375 with the Vanguard SIPP. The other key point is that the Interactive Investor SIPP has no minimum contribution levels, unlike the Vanguard SIPP which has a minimum monthly investment of £100 or a lump sum of £500.

The other benefit of an Interactive Investor SIPP is that you have access to a wider range of investments (including ETFs, investment trusts and shares) and not just Vanguard funds (the Vanguard SIPP only offers Vanguard funds). Furthermore, if you change your mind in the future and decide that you would prefer to invest directly into the Vanguard SIPP you can do so without any exit fee.

Another, less popular but cost-effective SIPP alternative is iWeb but unlike Interactive Investor it does charge exit fees if you decide to move your money away from iWeb in the future.

Vanguard Investor SIPP vs Interactive Investor SIPP

Interactive Investor has three service plans, charging a monthly fee (regardless of your portfolio size) of £9.99, £13.99 or £19.99, depending on what service plan you choose. Vanguard charges a fixed percentage of 0.15% (capped at £250,000, meaning the maximum is £375 per year). There is also an underlying fund charge, but the charge is the same for both Interactive Investor and Vanguard Investor. So, if you intend to invest more than £160,000 into a Vanguard SIPP, then you may as well invest in Vanguard funds through Interactive Investor's SIPP as it will be cheaper.

Of course, if you never plan to hold more than £160,000 in a Vanguard SIPP then you would be better off investing via Vanguard's own SIPP (when it launches) as it would be cheaper. However, one of the advantages of investing in an alternative platform such as Interactive Investor is that you are able to invest in a wider range of funds. With Vanguard you are limited to Vanguard's own funds. Additionally, investing in a SIPP using a platform such as Interactive Investor will give you access to thousands of investment trusts, ETFs and unit trusts from hundreds of investment companies, access to direct share dealing, a wider range of ethical investing options as well as no minimum investment restrictions.

Finally, you need to consider any costs associated with drawdown. The Vanguard SIPP does not charge for going into drawdown, whereas Interactive Investor charges £120 per year. If you enter drawdown using an Interactive Investor SIPP (which is one of the cheapest for drawdown in the market) then costs would rise to £359.88 per year. This means you would need to hold at least £240,000 for Interactive Investor to be cheaper, and even then, you would only be making a saving of £15.12 per year.

Of course, you are free to transfer from one SIPP provider to another prior to going into drawdown if you want to maximise cost savings pre and post-retirement. Remember the cheapest SIPP pre-retirement is not necessarily the cheapest SIPP post-retirement.

Pros and cons of the Vanguard SIPP

Pros

  • low account fee of 0.15%, capped at £375 per year
  • no annual administration fee
  • no setup or exit fees
  • no drawdown fees

Cons

  • high minimum investment when compared to other SIPP providers
  • limited to Vanguard's own funds
  • investors with more than £160,000 can invest in Vanguard funds via a SIPP more cheaply elsewhere

Summary

The Vanguard SIPP is a great cost-effective pension product. However, if you like Vanguard funds and are considering investing in a Vanguard SIPP then it may be worth considering opening a SIPP with a platform such as Interactive Investor or iWeb and we have summarised the reasons below:

  • If you have £160,000 or more to invest then it will be likely cheaper to invest in Vanguard funds with Interactive Investor or iWeb than with Vanguard Investor directly.
  • More choice as you are not restricted to just Vanguard funds. Via Interactive Investor or iWeb you can invest in thousands of unit trusts, investment trusts, ETFs and shares.
  • No exit fee with Interactive Investor so if you ultimately decide to invest directly through Vanguard Investor then you can transfer across without penalty. iWeb does charge exit fees, unfortunately.
  • Consider potential drawdown costs before you commit to a provider but ultimately the cheapest SIPP pre-retirement will differ from the Cheapest SIPP post-retirement (see our drawdown comparison article).

In December 2019 I was personally invited into Vanguard's offices in central London in order to take an exclusive look at the Vanguard SIPP ahead of its launch. I talk more about my visit and provide an early review of the Vanguard SIPP in episode 249 of the Money to the Masses podcast. Check it out below (skip to 17 minutes)

 

 

Looking for a financial adviser near you?

Do you need financial advice? An independent financial adviser can show you how to make the most of your money.

Simply find your nearest qualified and regulated adviser using the UK’s largest adviser search.

Send this to friend