Robo-advisers have become popular in recent years as an easy, low-cost way of creating an investment portfolio. They help investors to identify an investment approach that matches their risk appetite and return requirements, filtering them into a suitable portfolio, which they then manage on the investors’ behalf. Robo-advisers are generally targeted at those with relatively little investment knowledge or experience or those who don’t have the time or expertise to manage their own portfolio.
What is a robo-adviser?
Robo-advisers were developed as an alternative to discretionary wealth managers, who created bespoke portfolios for their clients, but with fees that put them out of reach for most people. Instead, robo-advisers use algorithms that, by analysing prospective investors’ answers to a series of questions, can suggest the best match from within their range of investment portfolios.
Once someone has opened an account and invested in the suggested portfolio, the robo-adviser manages that portfolio for the investor, adjusting the allocations within it to ensure it continues to match the risk/return profile. They are then required to check regularly - generally once a year - to make sure the investors’ needs are the same and that the portfolio is still suitable for them.
While a variety of investment platforms call themselves “robo-advisers”, for the purposes of this article, our definition of a robo-adviser is an online offering that uses a questionnaire to ascertain someone’s attitude to risk and capacity for loss. This questionnaire then leads to a suggested portfolio, including information on the underlying asset allocation. This definition excludes those platforms that only require someone to define themselves as “cautious”, “moderate” or “adventurous” without asking further questions to check whether this self-assessment is accurate.
Robo-advisers generally state that they offer “guidance” rather than “advice”. This is because “advice” comes with its own regulatory burden and, instead, this approach presents potential investors with an option, but the responsibility of making the final decision rests with the investor.
Which is the best robo-adviser in the UK?
In the table below, we highlight our pick of the best robo-advisers currently available in the UK. Our in depth analysis led us to identify 4 providers, which excelled in specific categories, as well as providing good all-round products and services.
|Number of portfolios||Account types||Ethical Portfolios||Minimum investment||Money to the Masses sign up offers|
|Nutmeg||10 Fully Managed
5 Fixed Allocation
5 Smart Alpha
|ISA, General Investment Account, Junior ISA, Lifetime ISA and SIPP||10||£500 (£100 for JISA and LISA)||No management fees for 12 months (terms and conditions apply)|
|Wealthify||5||ISA, General Investment Account, Junior ISA and SIPP||5||£1 (£50 for SIPP)||n/a|
|Moneyfarm||7||ISA, General Investment Account, Junior ISA, SIPP||7||£500||No management fees for 12 months (terms and conditions apply)*|
|InvestEngine||10 Growth portfolios
3 Income portfolios
|ISA, General Investment Account||n/a||£100||£25 welcome bonus (terms and conditions apply)|
Best low-cost robo-adviser
Although InvestEngine is relatively new to the market, it has gained popularity among both DIY investors, who are keen to take advantage of the fact it has no dealing or account fees, and those looking for a managed portfolio. For the latter, there is a choice of growth or income portfolios, both of which attract an annual platform fee of just 0.25%, which is significantly lower than for its rivals. There is no charge for setting up an account or withdrawing funds, although there are ongoing charges for the underlying ETFs that populate the portfolios. According to InvestEngine, this is around 0.22%, which is lower than the majority of other robo-advisers. To find out more, check out our full independent review of InvestEngine.
Best robo-adviser for choice
While robo-advisers can offer as few as 3 different portfolios - generally labelled as "cautious", "balanced" or "adventurous" - Nutmeg has 10 risk-rated portfolios in its Fully Managed range, which are numbered from 1 to 10 and have varying degrees of exposure to equities. However, in addition to the main Fully Managed range, there are a further 10 portfolios in its Socially Responsible range, which mirror the risk ratings on the main range but invest in companies that have high environmental, social and governance standards.
As well as the Fully Managed and Socially Responsible portfolios, what sets Nutmeg apart is the fact it also has a Fixed Allocation range and Smart Alpha portfolios. The fixed allocation range is based on a more "hands-off approach", with the investments automatically rebalanced but only formally assessed once a year. Its 5 risk-rated portfolios are available at a lower cost than the main range. Meanwhile, the 5 Smart Alpha portfolios are actively managed by J.P. Morgan Asset Management, with the potential for enhanced returns. To find out more, check out our full independent review of Nutmeg.
Best robo-adviser for customer service
Moneyfarm is currently the only robo-adviser that incorporates personal advice from an investment professional as part of its core proposition. As such, investors can discuss their investment choices, objectives and wider financial decisions, such as retirement planning, either over the phone, via online chat or in a face-to-face consultation. This service is included in the overall platform fee, which starts at 0.75% for accounts up to £10,000, through to 0.35% for those investing more than £500,000.
According to Moneyfarm, both the digital investment process and the "personal advice" is guidance rather than regulated advice. However, it is certainly a useful service to double-check the portfolio you've chosen is the most appropriate for you, as well as providing you with support on decisions about market conditions or if your circumstances change. To find out more, check out our full independent review of Moneyfarm.
Best robo-adviser for usability
Although all robo-advisers aim to be user friendly, some are more successful than others. Wealthify is particularly strong in this field, with an easy-to-navigate website and intuitive onboarding process, as well as a useful app, which makes it simple to manage your investments from your phone.
What we particularly like about Wealthify, however, is the feature that allows you to easily visualise the difference between the portfolios by using sliders which then shows you the likely return you are likely to get over a set period of time. The timeframe is adjustable and it also shows you how your portfolio could perform if markets perform worse or better than average over that period. It's easy to move between the 5 portfolios on the original plan, as well as moving to its ethical plan, allowing you to draw direct comparisons. To find out more, check out our full independent review of Wealthify.
Advantages of robo-advisers
Robo-advisers offer a cheaper service than a traditional discretionary manager for two main reasons: they don’t attract the same management charges and the underlying investments, which tend to be passive funds, have lower ongoing charges.
By investing in a portfolio from a robo-adviser you are automatically exposed to a range of asset classes, including equities and bonds. The allocation will vary depending on the level of risk, but you will generally be invested in a wide range of underlying holdings.
A robo-adviser portfolio offers a straightforward solution as the asset allocation and day-to-day management is taken care of. There isn’t the requirement to select your own funds or rebalance the portfolio or react to short-term market movements.
Disadvantages of robo-advisers
While robo-advisers use a questionnaire to help guide you to the most suitable portfolio, they don’t offer a tailor-made product that is specifically targeted at your individual needs. While you will be in a category that generally matches your needs, this can still be quite broad. There also isn’t usually the option to modify your portfolio, although some robo-advisers do offer separate options where you can pick your own funds from within a set range that they have available.
Not suitable for short-term investments
Although robo-advisers generally offer good levels of diversification in their portfolios, there is certainly no guarantee that they will always provide the level of return the investor is looking for and they will be subject to the same fluctuations that can be expected in any portfolio. For this reason, it is better to have a longer-term time horizon and to try to avoid making dramatic changes driven by short-term market events.
Guidance not advice
Although with the moniker “robo-adviser” you would be forgiven for thinking that the portfolio recommendation you are given during the onboarding process constitutes advice, it is actually “guidance” and there are no guarantees it will actually suit your specific needs. An automated questionnaire, while offering a quick, easy and low-cost option, should not be seen as a substitute for a full face-to-face consultation with an investment adviser.
Summary: Should you invest in a robo-adviser?
Robo-advisers are certainly a good option for certain types of investors, particularly beginners or those who do not have the confidence to put together and manage their own portfolios. Although they have always been a cost-effective way to invest, as the number of robo-advisers has increased, they have become even more competitively priced, which also increases their appeal. While we've highlighted the importance of cost, service, choice and usability, for some, the choice simply comes down to performance and so you may wish to check out our article "Which is the best performing stocks and shares ISA", where we take a look at the performance of a number of robo-advisers over the last three years.
In addition to the examples of robo-advisers we have outlined above, there are managed portfolio options available from other platforms, however they don't have the same questionnaire process in place as with true robo-advisers. There are also a plethora of do-it-yourself platforms for those who want to choose their own underlying investments. We highlight the best of all of these in our article "The best investment platform".
If a link has an * beside it this means that it is an affiliated link. If you go via the link Money to the Masses may receive a small fee which helps keep Money to the Masses free to use. But as you can clearly see this has in no way influenced the above editorial. The following links can be used if you do not wish to help Money to the Masses or take advantage of the exclusive Money to the Masses offers - Moneyfarm and Wealthify